D578 Image

AnyTone over Motorola for DMR?

I get a lot of people asking me about Motorola or Hytera radio. It seems like some of them think they want the commercial radio and are looking for support in that decision.

For most people I don’t think a commercial radio is a good choice…except in a few cases.

The biggest case is for visiting repeater sites. Both Motorola and Hytera have better receivers and get deal with the high levels of RF on at a busy repeater site. Some other radios can’t

Let me explain. I started using DMR in about 2014 DMR neither Motorola nor Hytera have released anything new. Yes, Motorola came out with the “i” models, but they do nothing for Hams except cost more. They have each released some minor features, but nothing significant for Tier II users.

Motorola still has not added support for the ETSI changes that came in 2017. This includes the Talker Alias feature that would make contact management so much easier on Motorola radios. Hytera updated their radios and repeaters, which is nice. MMDVM and OpenSpot support these new features as well. Why not Motorola?

Motorola and Hytera are both focused on the PTT over Cellular (POC) solutions and P25 or TETRA for public service. Not on DMR.

A limit of 1,000 contacts is frustrating. Without the ability to import/export contacts the frustration runs even deeper.

Here are some of the reasons AnyTone works for me:

  • dual band
  • dual receive
  • analog APRS
  • VFO mode
  • monitor/promiscuous mode
  • active development of CPS and firmware, including new features
  • large contact list with import
  • all programming can be exported, manipulated outside CPS and imported
  • supports current ETSI spec

Yes, the Motorola radios are a little more rugged. They are also more expensive and offer fewer features. This is particularly true for amateurs.


Join the conversation

comment 3 comments
  • Howard Clayton KG5RBG

    I have prefered Motorola even up to the current date, but I really do think that the Anytones can be a fantastic addition.My primary mobile and shack rigs are XPRs as the local repeater programming rarely changes, but I definitely see the advantages of the Anytones while the hotspot is fired-up. I was impressed the first time I picked up an 878. Felt really solid.

  • David G Lopez

    Thank you for the information!!!!!

  • Rick WA6ES

    Thanks for this since I am looking for a mobile unit. Interesting that Anytone and Alinco look like brothers so also looking at the Alinco since I have the HT version.

Leave a Reply to Howard Clayton KG5RBG Cancel reply

%d bloggers like this: